New: As pointed out by a few friends, along with many good things (detailed below), simple marriages entail a couple of problems: A) Loss of jobs for the poor, if the money saved by avoiding a grand wedding stays locked up in the bank B) It may get spent on environmentally unfriendly things like big, power-hungry appliances and fuel-guzzling outings. However, if simplicity is combined with charity [i.e., the money saved is used for social work], low-cost weddings are undoubtedly the way to go, for the overall good. About whatever you can’t donate, it’s best to spend it in ways which route the highest % of your money to the poor – shopping from local vendors/NGOs (not malls), hiring an adequately paid cook/maid, etc. – hurting the climate the least [More/Specifics].
NB: Recent updates highlighted in red.
Characters Involved:
-
Sejal: She currently works with Wipro Bangalore [telecom sector]. A native of Ahmedabad, she has done BE EC from DDIT, Nadiad (Gujarat). More on her blog and Orkut page.
-
Pulkit (This intro is meant for the first-timers on this blog): He currently works with HP Labs Bangalore [R&D in image processing]. A native of Ahmedabad, he has done MS by Research from IIIT, Hydearabad and BE IT from Nirma Institute, Ahmedabad. More on his Orkut page and here.
Marriage Theme We Followed:
Divert the marriage money to community development. In plain words, keep the wedding simple and support NGOs/social work from the money saved [Yes, this has to be over and above your other/regular donations] [More].
Theme B – Match your wedding expense with donations:
If you are unable to keep the marriage low-key, make a donation matching (a percentage of) the wedding expense. It’s also crucial to transact with small players [bandwalas for DJs, local cloth/jewelery shops over branded showrooms, modest restaurants/caterers] for suppressing inequality.
Wedding Venue: Arya Samaj (Mandir), Ahmedabad. None of us expected such a spacious place for 2200 bucks ['pundit'/ritual material included]! Our first choice, though, was the Marriage Registrar’s office.
Spectators: Immediate relatives (around 20 from either side)
Events: Just the marriage ceremony with rituals, followed by lunch in a nearby restaurant [No reception, music night, etc.]
Exchange: After a number of requests/arguments, we managed to ensure minimal give-and-take of gold and gifts, but couldn’t avoid the exchange totally.
Why Simple Marriage?: Nah, there was no ulterior motive of saving up money for a grand honeymoon in Switzerland or something like that :).
-
We believe that the galactic sums of money spent on flashy marriages should be diverted to better causes. This prompted us to celebrate our wedding through donations to needy NGOs. It is true that conventional marriages help in money rotation, benefiting some of the poor. But, typically, only a part of what you spend for the wedding descends to the poor. Contrastingly, when you donate to a genuine NGO, most of your money reaches the needy. Besides, there exist countless opportunities, other than the wedding, for rotating i.e. spending your money (without harming the environment substantially). [More in the 1st paragraph]
-
Expensive marriages have almost become a must, due to the fear of what “people” will think otherwise. Many (especially low-income) families are forced into taking hefty loans to account for the wedding expense. We wanted to emphatically break this unwritten societal norm. No one should be forced in the name of customs/society (for any matter).
-
Because the marriage cost mostly falls on the shoulders of the girl parents, costly marriages (along with dowry) cause parents to prefer a son over a daughter (grossly unfair to women) #. While the ideal solution to this is equal sharing of the expense between the girl folks and guy folks, the best short term solution is to keep the marriage cost nominal, so that a major reason for not wanting a girl child goes away *.
-
We wanted to avoid the pollution through fire crackers [Over a lakh small kids labour in the hazardous and harmful surrounds of cracker manufacturing units], food wastage [Average marriage-wasted food can feed ten families for a week]. A true environment lover can also question the decorative lighting [Most of today's energy is produced by burning coal in thermal power stations, emitting harmful gases], travels (esp. flights) by the invitees and traffic jams through the barat.
-
A guest list boasting 500+ invitees to the wedding is not the only way to foster relationships. We would much rather divide these guests into smaller chunks based on commonness, and invite them to our house for separate get-togethers, enabling much more meaningful interaction.
For Those Who Support this Marriage Theme:
We feel good to have your support. But, this feel-good factor won’t contribute to creating a better society. To make a difference, all of us need to aggressively practice this theme in our lives. This theme of celebrating through donations is generic, applicable to all your special events (b’days, anniversaries, academic successes, first jobs, promotions), not just the marriage. However, this should NOT de-emphasize the practice of donating a part of your salary, every month.
An Implementation Bottleneck:
If you are put off from donations because you can’t catch hold of a reliable NGO, feel free to contact me. Here’s where all we have donated. You could also go through this exhaustive list of ways-to -contribute.
Marriage Intimation Card:
Wondering why a simple marriage needs a wedding card? Well, our card encompasses much more than a wedding announcement. Through it, we convey the rationale behind the low-profile wedding to our acquaintances. It also serves as a way of promoting the theme of simple marriages coupled with contributions to social work, so that more of us adopt similar ways. The e-card option was ruled out since not all people back-home are net-savvy. Instead, we made Gujarati letters.
We got the cards prepared from environment-friendly [hand-made] paper by the kids of Arzoo (an Ahmedabad-based NGO), to support the education and livelihood of those disadvantaged children. We advocate the use of this kind of charity greeting cards, as opposed to the Arches kind [Ideally, we should replace paper-based cards by e-cards, wherever possible].
Why Make the Donations Public?:
However big an amount you donate (and however many hours you put in for social work), a small set of individuals/NGOs can never hit inequity hard enough. To make a real difference, much greater participation is needed, which can only be attained through increased willingness and awareness in all of us towards our roles in creating a fairer society. The most effective way of getting that message across is to share your actions with people, hoping that just like their good deeds inspire you, some of your efforts will spark a thought in them.
Convincing the Parents:
We got them to view this as a special opportunity of contributing to the society. Still, there remained a bit of resistance, as anticipated. But, with time, seeing that our beliefs were unshakable, they softened their stance and have been supportive ever since. Now, they are super happy about this marriage theme. So, the key is to tell yourself that mom-dad’s current unhappiness will soon turn into joyous pride. Don’t be driven by momentary emotions. Show commitment to your noble plans. The buzzword is strong-minded persistence. Our advice: Start (casually) telling parents about your simple marriage plans from today itself.
Unanticipated Recognition:
Mom was distributing the marriage cards in her bank where an employee of Divya Bhaskar, a leading Gujarati daily, caught hold of a copy. Soon, I was called up for more details. A day later, the newspaper published an article centered around the new marriage mantra: Combine simplicity and charity. The literal translation of its title would be “With simplicity, came the barat; the bride-groom will donate one-and-a-half lakh”. There is a slight slip in this, as the amount pledged by us is 1 lakh; my parents want to contribute the additional 50k.
More Photos:
# For many financially ill-equipped parents, the birth of a girl means over two decades of cost cutting (to ensure enough savings for the daughter’s marriage).
* Even those of us, who ourselves do not engage in any gender-based discrimination, should bear this point in mind because this is about setting the right trends in the society [People with less education/privileges are immensely influenced by the actions of people like us].
Heartly Congratulations to both of you…!!!
Wish you all the best.
We 99its are proud of you Pulkit.
Great.. very motivating act.
Congratulations to both of you.
awesome.
congratulation pulkit.
Wishing you and your wife a happy life.
Regard
Viji
CONGRATULATIONS….
that was really fantastic…..
hope people adopt this way for a better life of many
Hey.. congrats!!
Congratulations Pulkit…
Your empathy for the society is really exemplory….
Thanks everyone for your wishes.
Hey Sejal,
Congratulations!! Happy married life ahead…..
Sagar
I am nobody to you. But I completely share all your concerns and completely agree.
I had planned to get married in Auroville (Pondicherry) away from known family/friends at similar costs inviting only the immediate family and the registered marriage.
When you come from an upper middle class family, ostentatious display becomes imperative. Sadly, even if you are working in the development sector, you might want to have aspirations of a lavish wedding. And for all those teeming millions who are doing without “Roti, Kapda and Makaan” we do nothing but choose to spend it on ourselves.
May I dare to suggest: If you want to celebrate the marriage – if you dearly want to – do the 25th anniversary by, maybe, feeding thousands and maybe more of poor, hungry children easily found in any part of India.
I had similar ideas too. Unfortunately, for some of these reasons and my principles and ideologies themselves, my marriage never took off! LOL! I remain single and could not marry the woman I have loved dearly for so many damn years (all my life, she’s a childhood friend!)
MANY MANY Congrats on your marriage and wonderful education. Your nobility will hold you in good stead for your future. And yes, if I can ever be of any help to such a noble couple, I would be most delighted to.
Heartiest congratulations to Sejal and Pulkit. You are an inspiration to the rest of us.
My heartiest congratulations. May you have many more weddings such as these ;-)
hi.
many-2 hearty wishes to both of u……….m nobody to u guys….this blog was fwdd to me by a cousin of mine……..
Its too late for me as i have been married for 2 yrs……..faced everything mentioned above…….
but yes u guys hav done really a great job……..
hope people will follow ur foot steps……n contribute their bit for the welfare of the society.
anvita
Hi…
well we are unknown 2 each other but somehow connected…in our motives n morals perhaps…
Anyways.. my hearty congratulations 2 both of u… may u hav successful years ahead..
Sejal n Pulkit u hav really done an appreciable job.. rather an inspirational one.. I think nw 2 make it more special on every anniversary u can arrange 4 some food 4 poors specially children.. They really need people like u…
if anyhow i could ever help u people in any respect i’ll be highly obliged.. For any help plz take a step ahead 2 me…rest i’ll manage…
Congratulations once again..Hav successful years ahead… n yes all the very best. May u always soar higher in ur motives…
Dear Sejal & Pulkit,
Congratulations.
We did the same thing (in fact only in Registrar’s office) 20 years back in presence of parents only.
Probably needless to mention… for the same cause.
nikhil
To Nikhil: Thanks. Good to know that we followed your foot steps :). Regards.
Congratulations Sejal!! that was really fantastic…..
Happy married life ahead…..
Regards
Dilip
Congratulations, Pulkit! May you have a happy married life…!
Hi,
This mail was fwded to me by one of our colleagues in our company. No, doubt you people have done a appreciable job rather an inspirational one. Since, as far as i am concerned marriage is neither on the cards right now nor quite a few years down the lane hence ,i would certainly like to add something here which i personally started feeling from a fortnight or so(doing something for my country has always been my foremost and childhood dream) and the two things which happened recently that inspired me most ; one is the recent show which started in StarOne & an episode which was on air in Discovery channel. Coming to the first case ; its LeadIndia from StarOne , here i would surely like to add why i am specifically mentioning Lead India. This is because here one gets to know how people who are in a lot better position than what we are right now , making immense sacrifices & hard work to help the downtrodden people here in India & contributing in other constructive works thus playing an immense role for the upliftment of our country. Secondly,coming to Discovery channel which was aired a few days ago wherein Ashley Judd(a famous US celebrity) coming to India for AIDS awareness program and trying to know the real reason why India is now one of the most dreaded place where AIDS is spreading like wild fire. The way she interacted with Truck drivers, prostitutes,call girls, slum dwellers, uneducated people who had no idea how exactly AIDS spreads was really heart whelming. Now, as to why i am saying all these & what this has to do with the current topic might be confusing as of now. What my sole purpose of me doing this is, I just wanted to share a thought wherein cases as lavish as upper middle class marriage are concerned. Taking the case of girls family they easily spend around 25-35(30 avg)lacs & 10-15(12.5avg)lacs where the groom is concerned. If we consider a few exchange of gifts which we find quite imperative a meager 2-2 lacs from either side would surely solve the purpose where we save a whopping((30+12.5)-(2+2))= 38.5lacs. Now, with such a stupendous amount one can think quite big rather than just limiting in feeding hundreds of underprivileged children for once or donating to any NGO(which will no doubt be temporary).By something BIG i mean, We can think of taking the responsibility of the future education of 5-6 of these children or say we can think of something about India’s Wildlife(coz personally i had always thought of doing something for such a Sweet gift of God to mankind who are innocent & dumb.)Wish you people all the best for your future & i would gladly like to help in any way i can for anything that goes for the upliftment of our country. i can be contacted @ dev_prakash_rout@yahoo.co.in.
Thanks Dev for sharing your thoughts here. I agree that education is important but there are a few aspects I would like to mention:
1) Seju and I never proposed to give food. While that’s a good gesture, it’s not sustainable. But, supporting good NGOs surely is. You need people fighting in all spheres – health, livelihood, policies, education and more. NGOs/social welfare groups are a collection of those people/activists.
To continue to fight for social uplifting and justice, these NGOs need regular monetary support. Thus, I urge to revisit your thoughts on NGOs. Of course, I am only speaking of genuine ones. A very good NGO that would interest you is Asha for education (ashanet.org), dedicated to the sphere of education.
2) When we say we wanna “educate” kids, let’s think it through. Assume that all these funded kids pass std 10. Will they get a job? NO.
From my experience of a couple of years with slum people, it is unlikely that the kids will go beyond std 10, given the kind of environment they have at home. But assuming optimistically that they will go on past std 12th, where are the jobs? How will you convince their parents to allow them to go further from here (graduation) when they can quit the studies and get labour jobs?
3) How will we ensure that money won’t spoil the ways of young boys? Don’t we know about gutkhas and alchohol?
So, what I am coming to is that money alone won’t solve their problems. They need mentoring. They need more than phycics, chemistry and maths. They need to be (also) made aware of human values – the rights and the wrongs, how things work. They need counseling and tutoring, at all levels, not just academic. That’s where NGOs come in when they devote their time and skills to make sure that their donors’ money actually serves the designated purpose of education – to empower people to be self-reliant.
Hope I am able to make my point clear.
All this isn’t meant to dishearten anyone. I surely want us to contribute to education. But I want us to better-planned and well-rounded. The other point is that livelihood and health are closely connected with education.
** What if there are no jobs after graduation?
** Even if we get almost all kids educated, we are still gonna need blue-collar workers. There is no doubt about that. So, why shouldn’t we work for their rights – assure minimum wages, assure healthy and less hazardous working conditions and so on.
** I deem “providing basic health care” as the first priority. Doing that involves awareness (where education can help to a certain extent) and disease management. So, you need money there as well. There is also the aspect of health policies as health gets increasingly privatized.
In summary, these are all interconnected issues. Let us respect them all and more importantly, try to solve them all!
Happy and enlightened to have this discussion with you, Dev. Thanks again.
With due respect , of what you have written Pulkit (I know you are elder to me seen world more than me & hence by all means more experienced than me) I would like to share upon my thoughts in these cases pointed by you.
1.I know you & Sejal never proposed in giving food , i just mentioned that point coz i found it in someones suggestion in this blog. I’m really sorry for this misinterpretation as it was never meant for you people. Yes, boss i fully agree supporting NGOs for a good cause is no doubt far from effective. I had never any grudges against them, I was just trying to make it a point that if one takes a personal responsibility then perhaps………(as i had earlier mentioned you have a far better idea about NGOs then I)
2.Coming to assuring one of getting a job. I fully agree with you but (correct me if i’m wrong) are you sure that education guarantees each & everyone a job ??? I have seen guys completing their Engineering & are still jobless. What i want to say hear is we can never guarantee anyone a job. So, i was thinking education by all means was necessary irrespective whether one lands up with a decent job or not. With the amount of money I was talking, no doubt it would be enough till graduation & as far as convincing their parents is concerned i think not all are inconvincible probably by assuring them that all the monetary issues will be handled by us. I repeat i’m least experienced in all these matter so i might be talking something that comes straight from a fairy tale.
3.As you are saying that you have experience with slum people no doubt you must be very much correct. And so with your view point regarding gutkas & alcohol. But, i think we can make the fund transfer to that particular school or college without giving that lumsome amount into their hands & as mentioned earlier we can take personal responsibility & make it a point that the fund dosent go towards spoiling the child instead of his/her betterment.
I very well agree that to is that money alone won’t solve their problems. They need mentoring. They need more than phycics, chemistry and maths. They need to be (also) made aware of human values – the rights and the wrongs, how things work. They need counseling and tutoring, at all levels, not just academic. And NGOs play a handy role in all of these. So, i was never against them. I feel lot of these issues making(aware of human values – the rights and the wrongs, how things work) education will surely help.
I do understand all these things are better said than done but life after all was never ever easy. Lastly, i would like to say that all of this was just sharing my view points & not by any means meant in any kind of arguments for i solely agree to the fact that you are more experienced & understand the actual scenario more than me. Please do point where you feel i am going wrong & please do contact me if i can be of any help for this noble cause. Thanks for sharing your thoughts & making me see the real issue.
Our blessings to you both Pulkit and Sejal. May you both have a happy and a fullfiling life togather.We,my husband Prithvi
and I are way older than you .We were simply delighted to know
that there are indeed, young people who care about underprivilaged and marginalised people in India and think about their role in creating a just society by sacrifying their personal resources ,time and energy. You have have set a good example by having a simple marriage and donating the money for the upliftment of the exploited ones. You have set a path for setting the right trends and upholding the right values in the society. May this message of yours inspire more
young people to do the same.Our LOVE and BLESSING!
SUREKHA and PRITHVI.
Hearty Congratulations – Pulkit and Sejal. This is truly inspirational. More than the simple wedding, love the way you have communicated it & inspiring others. Fantastic deed, keep it up!
Congratulations, Sejal and Pulkit. I wish you a very very happy married life. Felt very happy to read your thoughts and the discussions in Comments section.
I very much agree with the thoughts you mentioned in the section, ‘why make donations public?’.
It is very true. If everyone of us think about society and perform our duties and fulfill our responsibilities as a citizen, there would not be poverty, backwardness and any other evil that we can talk about.
Please visit these urls when you find time:
http://groups.google.com/group/birdsofsamefeathers
http://prasanthi.uppalapati.googlepages.com
Birds of same feathers is a platform for all likeminded groups working on different social causes. This is to share information, inspire each other and also to work together wherever possible.
Thank you.
with regards,
Prasanthi.
prasanthi.uppalapati@gmail.com
My heartiest congratulations and Best wishes to Sejal and Pulkit.
Its not just your thoughts and writings,But, your actions are quite reflecting them & inspiring.
I always used to think about the flashy grand marriages and the lumpsum amounts which go into many temples towards God and jewels which can be turned towards betterment of the underpriviliged in the society.But, could not take any major action towards this.
As I see one live example here,I am truley inspired and happy.
As you said “Don’t be driven by momentary emotions”. Yes, If every one can manage to do it,they can see the actual position of the society and the work required towards it.
Best wishes to you both.Keep going in same spirit.
Regards,
Suhasini
Wonderful thoughts and gesture.Simple marriage where rituals are more important than the lavishness, was a budding thought in my mind.Now it has taken a proper shape with your inspirational act.
Best Wishes!!
~Amitha
[...] A Glimpse into My Marriage (photo-rich!) [...]
[...] it’s an era of theme weddings, we couldn’t help but find ourselves one. Our theme was diverting the marriage money to charity. In keeping with this theme, ours was a simple wedding wherein only immediate relatives were [...]
I m a ddit ec student.u have done a good work.
[...] was not to save money for themselves. The couple saved about 1.5 Lakhs and donated it to charity. Pulkit gives us the reasons: * Expensive marriages have almost become a must, due to the fear of what “people” will [...]
hey guys
Congrats first of all
Very appreciable job what u have done is must of inspirational to many . . .
Life Style Channels telecast BIG FAT WEDDINGS . . .
showing very lavish wedding on air, there the couple go on saying we had a very simple marriage . . .
Awesome and inspiring,
You guys are simply amazing!…. I hope that I’ll take a leaf out of your story and wish my marriage to happens the same way :).
Awesome Man…. that’s the right thing to do. I hope to do it the same way. Not hope, its too weak. I expect to do the same!
I am Charu’s father. I was overhelmed by your idea and will try to follow in my Son’s marriage. Refarding Charu’s marriage expanses it depends upon the response from other side. i will suggest that if you can quantify the benefits in terms of money saved/donated and energy saved and thus humble contribution to reduction in global warming it will help to propagate the idea. By the way any idea about how many people got inspired and emulate your example.
Rohit
Elated to hear of your plans, Rohit uncle! About quantification, I see where you are coming from, but different people/regions/cultures spend different sums on the wedding. Moreover, brandishing that, in my case, may also be perceived as self-publicity, with the readers’ focus shifting from the cause to the author of the cause :). So, we chose not to highlight the monetary numbers, which clearly run in lakhs. Having said that, for a general appeal, they are a definite value addition, along with those for the energy/emissions savings, as you rightly mentioned. Please let me know if and how you would like me to do this.
I have received a massive number of comments – here and on emails, many finding this an idea worth adopting; but not sure how many have actually done it. A friend of mine adapted this theme (he somehow couldn’t do away with some of the luxury) to “matching donations” – donating the exact amount (2 lakhs in his case) he spent on his wedding, to various social change groups.